"I have been reading your amazing blog and listening to some of your podcasts with Carolyn. Not sure how I haven't run across your work before. Amazing stuff." (reader's comment, 10 May 2016)
Come chat with us! Download and install an IRC-client -- Hexchat is recommended -- and go to the channel #National-Socialism on the Undernet server.

21 August 2016

Warning about so-called “Official German Records of Prisoners in Auschwitz"

Recently I saw somebody post a link to an article about "Official German Records of Prisoners in Auschwitz Concentration Camp from May 1940 to December 1944." Then somebody sent me the same link by email. The links were to information on the "Darkmoon" blog, which I do not trust at all (because Darkmoon has been known to rely on utterly ridiculous sources)

To determine whether the information was credible, I tried to find where the information had been originally posted, but could not. I did find the same material posted in other places, however.

Whereas the compiler is credited only as "Admin" on the Darkmoon blog, on other sites, like Heretical, the compiler is named as "Germar Rudolf." In fact the compiler is one Peter Stahl, who falsely attached Germar Rudolf's name. 

On 21 August 2016 Rudolf sent out this repudiation:


Dear all:

Please be advised that I had no part in compiling the numbers listed below. That's one of Peter Stahl's disruptive activities. See my article on him here: http://www.vho.org/GB/c/GR/StahlDouglas.html

Stahl did that list I think back in 2002 or 2003 without my knowledge or consent, and it lingers on the net. I have never seen any of these microfilms myself. I remember that Stahl told me once that he has them, and at some point he even offered them to me. But I never had my hands on them, let alone studied them (if they exist). For all I know, this could all be made up. Stahl has a history of lying, and of manipulating or outright forging documents, and the fact that he falsely claimed I had compiled these numbers is a strong indicator that this is fishy. I wouldn't touch these numbers with a ten-foot pole. gr


Stahl's apocryphal figure for the total number of Jews who died in Auschwitz is 60,421. Arthur Butz' less precise but more trustworthy estimate from 1989 is "100,000-150,000" total deaths, of which "a large number would have been Jews" (A. Butz, JHR, fall 1989). It means that Stahl's presumably fictitious figures are toward the low end of what is likely. 

When making a controversial point, be sure that you know the original source of the information that you are using, and whether that source is credible.

No comments: